
A Promised Land
Book
A riveting, deeply personal account of history in the making-from the president who inspired us to...

BankofMarquis (1832 KP) rated The United States vs. Billie Holiday (2021) in Movies
Apr 17, 2021
Unfortunately, he tries to do so much with this film, that he accomplishes very little.
Let’s start with what works in this film: the TERRIFIC performance of Andra Day as the titular character. Day embodies the troubled artist strongly and she does all of the singing of this world renowned performer. It is a superb performance and she rightfully deserves her Oscar nomination.
What doesn’t work? Pretty much the rest of the film.
Daniels has so much material to work with - and a terrific actress at the center of it - that he tried to cram EVERYTHING into this film, consequently, the film is scattered and doesn’t know what it wants to be.
Is it a biopic? A look at an artist who overcame a horrific childhood? A look at an artist that is battling demons? A look at an artist that has toxic relationships with men? Or…is it about the United States Government trying to suppress free speech in order to keep the African American from rising up in the 1950’s?
The answer is…it is all of that…and none of that. Just when you think the film has it’s footing in one direction, it pivots in another and rarely gets back to tie off the other.
For example, look at the title of the film - THE UNITED STATES VS. BILLIE HOLIDAY. So, it must be about the United States (in this instance, the Federal Drug Agents) trying to bring Billie Holiday to justice. And…at the beginning it IS about that…namely in the guise of stopping her from singing STRANGE FRUIT and trying to frame her for her drug use. So…you would think that the film will, eventually, get Holiday on stage to sing a triumphant FULL version of Strange Fruit.
You would think that, wouldn’t you.
Now…to be fair to Daniels and this film, there is about a 15 minute portion of this film in the middle that shows Holiday’s heartbreaking childhood, followed by a haunting song sung by Day. It is a very effective portion of the film, and that (and Day’s performance) are worth wading through the “highlights and lowlights” of Holiday’s life that is the rest of this film.
I have not seen the lauded 1972 LADY SINGS THE BLUES that is a more straightforward Bio-pic of the singer (starring Diana Ross), after watching this film, I think I will.
Letter Grade: B- (because of Day’s performance and that 15 minute segment)
6 stars (out of 10) and you can take that to the Bank(ofMarquis)

Rhythm is Our Business: Jimmie Lunceford and the Harlem Express
Book
In the 1930s, swing music reigned, and the Jimmie Lunceford Orchestra was the hottest and hippest...

Happiness: A Novel
Book
A breathtaking novel from Orange Prize-shortlisted and Commonwealth Writers' Prize-winning author...

Water
Book
In his seminal photography books, Bernhard Edmaier combines his training as a geologist with an...

Cats of Egypt: An AUC Press Nature Foldout
Dominique Navarro and Richard Hoath
Book
Cats were just as favored in ancient Egypt as they are today. Egyptian paintings of domesticated...

Mick Hucknall recommended Bob Dylan by Bob Dylan in Music (curated)

Kurt Vile recommended Live At The East by Pharoah Sanders in Music (curated)

Life on the Mississippi
Book
The eagerly awaited return of master American storyteller Rinker Buck, Life on the Mississippi is an...

The Man with the Branded Hand: The Life of Jonathan Walker, Abolitionist
Book
Sailing around the Florida Keys in 1844, forty-five-year-old Jonathan Walker had a price on his...