One and Five Ideas: On Conceptual Art and Conceptualism
Book
In One and Five Ideas eminent critic, historian, and former member of the Art & Language collective...
Mike Birbiglia recommended Moonstruck (1987) in Movies (curated)
Super Fight
Tabletop Game
Superfight is a game where you argue with your friends over ridiculous fights. The game is very...
Argument cards create a hero draw to win
Caitlin Ann Cherniak (85 KP) rated Fantasyland: How America Went Haywire in Books
Oct 22, 2018
Don't get me wrong. This book has a couple of points, especially when he discusses religion and the Salem witch trails. However, when he starts getting into the more modern points of fantasy, either I didn't see it at all, or he was basically really poking fun at what the whole point of fantasy really is.
The title of the book is Fantasyland: How America Went Haywire. If he's going to use the word "Haywire" in a title, he better show pretty clear examples of why America is being flushed down the toilet. Poking fun at people cosplaying, playing video games, and being able to have fun at Disneyland or Disney World is not a point to say why America seems to be failing as a society. In fact, I can make a counterargument by saying that flights of fantasy in those contexts are actually forming the culture, not destroying it. Because of the evolution of entertainment (such as film, video games, etc.), it's easier to envision fantasy stories come to life. Before that, we had books, and no one was poking fun at books throughout this entire giant essay. Not only is that missing the forest for the trees, but it makes the argument of people being shown too much fantasy through visual mass media is a very shallow take on the topic of fantasy.
Also, the premise of the book talks about how people are arguing that Trump is ruining America because of his bullshit (and they're not wrong). I expected the book to discuss politics more in depth as a way to add onto the fantasyland argument. The book doesn't even do that, not even at the end when it "comes full circle" back to the Trump argument. If anything, the book kinda let it slide that it was for Trump and his radical ideas rather than finding flaws in them as people would expect. Look, if the book ended up explaining why Trump was trying to escape the Fantasyland argument, I'm all for reading that to make my own points. However, by just simply saying that Trump is being more realistic without any real reason, that also makes this essay a shallow writing. People want to read on why Trump has realistic views or not. If the point of this essay is talking about how fantastic ideas are plaguing a great nation, why not add that into the mix?
This essay was a real hit and miss for me. For something that's as thick as War and Peace, I expected this essay to have as juicy material as War and Peace, but it doesn't. It's just a 500 year rant on how "stupid" society can be, and that lost me as I finished the book.
In Focus: The Case for Privatising the BBC
Book
This book makes a persuasive argument that the licence fee is no longer the right way to raise...
New Power Politics of Global Climate Governance
Maximilian Terhalle and Charlotte Streck
Book
This book is based on the assumption that great powers determine global politics and, in this...
Protecting the Wild: Parks and Wilderness, the Foundation for Conservation
Tom Butler, George Wuerthner and Eileen Crist
Book
A big, bold vision for protected areas and re-wilding the Earth, this book presents a spirited...
Living My Life
Book
Anarchist, journalist, drama critic, advocate of birth control and free love, Emma Goldman was the...
The Unsinkable Titanic: The Triumph Behind a Disaster
Book
In this unparalleled investigation that deconstructs the modern hindsight that has tainted Titanic's...