The War of the Worlds and the War in the Air
Book
With an Introduction and Notes by Dr Andrew Frayn, Lecturer in Twentieth-Century Literature and...
Contemporary Monologues for Women
Book
In this volume of the Good Audition Guides, you'll find fifty fantastic speeches for women, all...
Broken Homes: The Fourth PC Grant Mystery
Book
Ben Aaronovitch has stormed the bestseller list with his superb London crime series. A unique blend...
Ross (3284 KP) rated Eurovision Song Contest: The Story of Fire Saga (2020) in Movies
Jul 8, 2020
The setting of the contest in Edinburgh was a nice touch, as with Infinity War it is always good to see the end product from the annoying road closures. However it didn't make sense, given the hosts were not British and Britain didn't win the contest, but again lets not take this too seriously. The car chase was a mess though, with the car one minute heading one way along a street and shortly appearing at a roundabout at the end behind them. Also, the Glasgow SSE Hydro arena being at the end of George IV Bridge was just all sorts of wrong.
The geographical inconsistencies aside, this is a nice silly little comedy that drags on a little too long with a fairly cliche'd plot.
Historic Streets & Squares: The Secrets on Your Doorstep
Book
Britain's favourite house historian investigates the stories behind our most famous streets and...
Shirley Manson recommended Head Over Heels by Cocteau Twins in Music (curated)
Ghost in the Machine
Book
For fans of Ian Rankin, Stuart McBride and Christopher Brookmyre, Ghost in the Machine is the novel...
Ticket to Ride: Europe
Tabletop Game
Ticket to Ride: Europe takes you on a new train adventure across Europe. From Edinburgh to...
Ross (3284 KP) rated Perfect Crime in Books
Feb 19, 2019 (Updated Feb 19, 2019)
The 5th book in the increasingly badly titled "DI Luc Callanach" series (he is hardly in this one!) follows much the same template as the other 4 books. A body is found in mysterious circumstances, here it is the body of a young man who appears to have thrown himself from the top of a tower in East Lothian. Soon thereafter, other bodies start to turn up, all looking like suicides or are people who had previously tried to commit suicide. At the same time, another body turns up, this time with a personal connection to one DI Callanach. So again we have the two investigations running in parallel. Though because of the apparent connection, the eponymous DI Callanach is taken off active duty and is largely absent for the second half of the book.
The main investigation is interesting: someone taking against those who do not value their life and have tried to end it in the past, and he decides to end it for them. However, there is a twist along the way that just did not feel right. For this murderer to suddenly become a Red Dragon-style character was somewhat at odds with the story at that point.
The lesser investigation was more interesting as there was so much evidence suggesting Callanach committed the murder, though we believed he hadn't.
As with previous books, a story written in Edinburgh (or other cities with an identity) by someone who doesn't live there has a good chance of missing the mark with the dialogue. People we are led to believe are proper sumbags do not come across as that, their phrasing is just so wrong. I had found this in the previous books, where incidental characters had no discernible voice or characteristics and were just vanilla plot devices.
Similarly, the murderer at one point uses a phrase no Scotsman has ever uttered and that took me right out of the book.
The plot is more or less faultless, with all events and motives seeming plausible, except one issue right at the end where an item of evidence was so mis-handled as to be laughable, but served the plot perfectly.
On the whole, this was a good enjoyable read, but I had guessed the identities of the murderers quite early on. Far from original and moments that just felt like clangers.
I am guessing this is almost the last we'll see of Luc Callanach, who has (rightly) been relegated to support cast from book 2, in favour of the strong, better-defined, female character.
Sarah Millican: The Biography of the Funniest Woman in Britain
Book
Cake baker, cat lover, agony aunt - she's one of the country's brightest new comedy talents. But who...