Smashbomb

Search

Search results

All (1125)

Content

The Hunter (Tales of Pern Coen: Bloodlines #1)

Hannah E. Carey

10.0 (1 Ratings) Rate It

Book

Forced to flee her uncle's palace in the dead of night in order to save her own life, Duchess...

Epic Fantasy Fantasy Romance

The Champion of The Ice (Legends of Elessia - Age of Rekindling #2)

Luís Falcão de Magalhães

(0 Ratings) Rate It

Book

The Daughter of The Ice is no more. But not even death will stop Her Champion’s march. Erika...

Fantasy Action and Adventure Dark Fantasy Trigger Warning: Violence and Death

Goddess in the Stacks (553 KP) rated Beasts Made of Night in Books

Apr 19, 2018

Beasts Made of Night

Tochi Onyebuchi | 2017 | Science Fiction/Fantasy

5.3

(3 Ratings)

Book Rating

Pretty cover. (0 more)

Terrible characters (3 more)

Lack of explanation of terms

Stupid cliffhanger

Confusing geography

So this Nigerian-influenced fantasy made enough of a splash when it was released in October that I JUST got it in my hands from the library. That long wait....was not actually justified, sadly. The cover is GORGEOUS and the concept is really, really cool - the execution is lacking. I can tell that the author had the world pretty fleshed out in his mind, from the geography to the vocabulary - but he didn't actually pass that knowledge on to the reader. Kos is a walled city, but I'm not sure whether the Palace is within the walls or not? In one scene our protagonist LEAPS out of the castle and runs back the city - but in another scene he mentions that looking out the castle wall, Kos fits behind his fingernail. Kos is made up of several neighborhood plus a market - it's not small. So either his fingernail is HUGE or Kos is a pretty decent distance away. But it's written as if it only takes him about ten minutes to run there? Not to mention that he cracked a rib in the room that he leaped from (which is never mentioned again).

Oh and he winds up landing in an ivy maze out of nowhere - he couldn't see it from the palace? Let's see....the King regularly bombards neighborhoods with catapults in what's called a "baptism" but the people haven't revolted against this, for some reason. They talk about something called a "kanselo" but never define it. I -think- it's like an organized group or coalition, but I'm really not entirely sure.

The male protagonist treats every woman his age as a potential love interest, debating whether to give them his heart-stone, or whether people will think he's already given one girl or another his heart-stone - but never stops to ask if the girls are interested in HIM that way. Because of COURSE they would be, right? He's the Sky-Fist! The Lightbringer! The one whose tattoos never fade! (Eating sin-beasts causes a black tattoo to appear on your skin - on most sin-eaters these fade eventually.) Also he's just DUMB. He recalls that the sin-eater who ate his mother's sin had a certain tattoo, and when he runs across her years later, it takes him three or four encounters before realizing it's the same sin-eater. (The tattoo is a spider. Covering her FACE. It hasn't faded.) He makes stupid decisions - after nightmares of one love-interest being attacked by sin-beasts, he LEAVES HER SURROUNDED BY THEM to go run out into the city. He has at least FIVE love interests in this book. And only ONE of them seems interested in him in return.

I really wanted to like this book. The concept of sin-eating is great. But the main character and all the one-dimensional characters that surrounded him, along with the confusing geography, just turned me off. And I'm not even getting into the "ending." Yeah. Definitely throwing quotes on that because that was not an ending. The book just stops.

Skip this. It was a terrible book wrapped in a deceptively pretty package.

You can find all my reviews at http://goddessinthestacks.wordpress.com