Search
Search results
Melanie Caldicott (6 KP) rated The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake in Books
Apr 29, 2021
I loved the concept of this books and as soon as I heard about it I was intrigued and wanted to read it. I read The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake in a couple of days, which with 3 children rarely happens, so I continued to find it intriguing and compelling throughout.
However, I found the narrative elusive and shadowy which was often frustrating. Whilst I understand that Bender was creating a narrative largely written from the perspective of a child, from whom many things were hidden and secret, I still found that as a reader you were constantly trying to grasp what she was describing and failing. I found this made the book less plausible and destroyed the intrigue turning it into annoying gameplay.
I have read other novels with narratives from the perspective of a child such as The Earth Hums in B Flat, The Book Thief, Mister Pip, The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, Room etc and found these all to be written far more skillfully than Bender manages here. It is an art to realistically write through the eyes of a child but reveal things to an adult reader through the child's naive perspective of the world. If this is failed to be achieved it can leave the reader feeling frustrated and disillusioned through being led on a journey that is over-constructed and inauthentic.
However, I found the narrative elusive and shadowy which was often frustrating. Whilst I understand that Bender was creating a narrative largely written from the perspective of a child, from whom many things were hidden and secret, I still found that as a reader you were constantly trying to grasp what she was describing and failing. I found this made the book less plausible and destroyed the intrigue turning it into annoying gameplay.
I have read other novels with narratives from the perspective of a child such as The Earth Hums in B Flat, The Book Thief, Mister Pip, The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, Room etc and found these all to be written far more skillfully than Bender manages here. It is an art to realistically write through the eyes of a child but reveal things to an adult reader through the child's naive perspective of the world. If this is failed to be achieved it can leave the reader feeling frustrated and disillusioned through being led on a journey that is over-constructed and inauthentic.
iamsara (130 KP) rated Wonder Woman (2017) in Movies
Nov 2, 2017
Clare Parrott (294 KP) rated Stitch It Simple: 25 hand sewn projects to make and share in Books
Nov 21, 2017
Clare Parrott (294 KP) rated Gentle Art of Quiltmaking in Books
Nov 21, 2017
Zackery Taylor (1 KP) rated Spotify Music in Apps
May 20, 2018
Kim Pook (101 KP) rated Game Of Thrones in TV
Jun 1, 2019
Peter G. (247 KP) rated Hannibal (2001) in Movies
Jun 5, 2019
Having already mentioned my late arrival to the Lecter franchise I found this to be the weakest entry but still very entertaining and Julianne moore although not as amazing as Jodie Foster, delivers a strong performance and once again Hopkins is as frighteningly evil as Lecter.
