
Hazel (1853 KP) rated These Shallow Graves in Books
Dec 17, 2018
Known for her young adult series about mermaids, Jennifer Donnelly also proves she is an excellent writer of historical murder mysteries. <i>These Shallow Graves</i> is set in the USA during the late 1800s where Josephine Montfort, a headstrong seventeen-year-old from a respectable family, is expected to marry well and produce a male heir. However, Jo’s innocent lifestyle is disrupted after her father’s mysterious death. With her passion for writing at the forefront of her mind, Jo rejects social etiquette and begins searching for answers.
Jo meets Eddie, a young, ambitious newspaper reporter who agrees to assist with her enquiries. However it is not as straightforward as Jo expects it to be. As the pair begin to uncover dangerous secrets, Jo is also witness to the injustices in the world. Life for the rich was a whole different world from that of the poor, but as Jo learns, that does not make anyone less worthy of being treated as a person.
<i>These Shallow Graves</i> is an exciting story that is gripping from beginning to end. Not only is there a crime to solve, Jo also ends up in a forbidden relationship that crosses the boundaries of her social status. From an historical point of view it is refreshing to read of a female challenging her position in society rather than being the naïve protagonist that many novels written during this time period contain. In some ways she is comparable to Jo March in <i>Little Women</i>, and not only because of their shared name.
Having read the first two books in the <i>Waterfire</i> saga, and been slightly disappointed with the writing style, I was a little apprehensive when beginning to read <i>These Shallow Graves</i>. I presumed I would get bored part way through, or find the narrative dreary, however I was pleasantly surprised. Donnelly is significantly better at historical fiction. The book was greatly researched thus the setting and dialogue were perfectly in keeping with the time period.
As with most murder mysteries the murderer is only revealed at the very end of the story. I guessed who it was fairly early on, however that is all it was, a guess. Most readers will be left hanging until the final chapters – will you work out who it was before then?

The Hindered Hand
Sutton E. Griggs, John Cullen Gruesser and Hanna Wallinger
Book
Between 1899 and 1908, five long works of fiction by the Nashville-based black Baptist minister...

A Dangerous Life (DCI Jack Callum #2)
Book
A tortured body is found hanging from a tree DCI Jack Cullum leads the investigation into this...
Historical Crime Fiction

Gun Island
Book
Bundook. Gun. A common word, but one which turns Deen Datta's world upside down. A dealer of rare...
Historical fiction Literary fiction India climate change Environment magical realism

The Murderess Must Die
Book
On a winter day in 1898, hundreds of spectators gather at a Brooklyn courthouse, scrambling for a...
Historical Fiction Crime

By the Light of Embers
Book
It's 1954, and twenty-two-year-old Lucia Lafleur has always dreamed of following in her father’s...
Historical Fiction Literary Fiction

ClareR (5950 KP) rated The Sin Eater in Books
Oct 5, 2021
Each sin in this book has a different food, which is how 14yr old May Owens learns that something sinister is going on in the Queen’s court.
May can’t tell anyone what she knows. It’s a terrible punishment for a young girl: sentenced to a life of silence and ostracised by everyone - all because she stole bread to eat. Ok, she’ll never go hungry, but some of the combinations are pretty grim!
I really enjoyed reading about the travelling entertainers, and the homeless people who decide that living with a walking, breathing curse (May) is worth the risk when it’s cold outside.
This is a really atmospheric book, steeped in the sights, sounds and smells of a 16th Century England-type-place, and it ticked a lot of boxes for me as a historical fiction, occasional fantasy fan (amongst the other types of fiction!!)

The Ministry of Time
Book
A BOY MEETS A GIRL. THE PAST MEETS THE FUTURE. A FINGER MEETS A TRIGGER. THE BEGINNING MEETS THE...
Speculative fiction Historical fiction time travel

The Curse of Maiden Scars (Maiden, Mother, Crone #1)
Book
Sixteen-year-old Renna Covert toils away in the shadows of a Yorkshire workhouse, her days filled...
Historical Fiction Women's Fiction
Poetic & Real Worlds of Cesar Vallejo (18921938): A Struggle Between Art & Politics
Book
The world-renowned Peruvian poet Cesar Vallejo (18921938) was also a journalist, essayist, novelist...