Anne (15117 KP) rated My Plain Jane: The Lady Janies Book 2 in Books
Nov 4, 2019
Jane Steele
7.5
Rate It
Book
'Reader, I murdered him.' JANE STEELE is a brilliant Gothic retelling of JANE EYRE from...
My Plain Jane: The Lady Janies Book 2
Jodi Meadows, Cynthia Hand and Brodi Ashton
8.3
Rate It
Book
You may think you know the story. After a miserable childhood, penniless orphan Jane Eyre embarks on...
romance fiction
Reader, I Married Him
Audrey Niffenegger, Francine Prose, Tracy Chevalier, Tessa Hadley, Patricia Park, Joanna Briscoe and Nadifa Mohamed
8.0
Rate It
Book
'This collection is stormy, romantic, strong - the Full Bronte' The Times A collection of short...
Jane
Book
Forced to drop out of an esteemed East Coast college after the sudden death of her parents, Jane...
Hazel (1853 KP) rated Jane Steele in Books
May 24, 2017
“Reader, I murdered him.” Jane Steele is a gothic retelling of the renowned Jane Eyre written by the celebrated Charlotte Bronte. Crime writer, Lyndsay Faye, creates an entirely new story, whilst appropriating the skeletal structure of the original classic. However, Jane Steele is nothing like the Miss Eyre everyone is familiar with. She is far more headstrong and independent, and also a murderer.
Before readers are discouraged to hear that their beloved Jane is portrayed as a criminal, the murders that occur are more of a homicidal or self-defense nature, as opposed to premeditated serial killing. In fact the first death, occurring when she is a nine year old orphan, is not her fault at all, however it prompts Jane’s wealthy aunt to pack her off to boarding school, and thus the similarities with Jane Eyre commence.
Written in an autobiographical manner, Jane describes her years at the virulent school, where she and the other girls experience abuse at the hands of the ignoble schoolmaster. As readers will recall, Eyre’s life improves in her later school years, however Jane Steele’s education comes to a premature end, resulting in her fending for herself in 19th century London.
As the blurb indicates, Jane returns to the house she grew up in after the death of her aunt, affecting to be a governess for the current owner’s ward. Mr. Charles Thornfield, a bachelor, is Jane Steele’s version of Rochester, minus the wife in the attic. The contents of the cellar, on the other hand, are a different matter…
From a romantic point of view, all happens in a similar manner to Jane Eyre, however this is where the comparisons end. With concealed crimes and secrets, as well as an unsolved murder, the story becomes the thriller it initially proposed to be. The incisive Jane Steele takes matters into her own hands – figuratively and literally – as she determines to resolve the unanswered questions.
Although not written with the intent to be comical, the stark contrasts between original and retelling create humorous scenarios. The nature of the main character in comparison with the time frame, a period where women had very little rights, makes the narrative far more exciting and amusing than the earlier novel – although not necessarily better.
Lyndsay Faye maintains the atmosphere of the 1800s with her affinity for eloquent turns of phrase and choice of words. She is a prolific author full of wonderful ideas; her ability to create a new story out of a well-known classic is a formidable skill. What is admirable is they way in which Faye has made Jane Steele a novel in its own right, and not merely a rip-off of Bronte’s work.
The skillful composition and wording will likely be loved by all, its only downfall being the reaction of hardcore Jane Eyre fans. Those who wish for the classics to be left alone and not pulled apart by contemporary authors or film directors may adopt a negative attitude towards to publication of Jane Steele. On the other hand, many will absolutely love this gothic retelling, appreciate the similarities and enjoy the new twist to the storyline. Personally, I am with the latter group.
Gwyneth Paltrow recommended Jane Eyre in Books (curated)
Stevie Nicks recommended Jane Eyre in Books (curated)
Erika (17788 KP) rated Jane Eyre in Books
Sep 16, 2017
