Shadows That Speak
Book
Daniel Manley did not experience a single moment of human kindness when cast out as a child onto the...
horror speculative bookbuzz thriller
Lost Shores of Thonis
Book
A year ago, Azizi's island home abruptly sank into the Mediterranean, drowning her family, culture,...
Historical Mystery Ancient Egypt
Redeem (The Caelian Cycle #2.5)
Book
A boy without a voice. A teen without a home. A man without hope. Kian knows the way his life...
Young Adult Dystopian Science Fiction Novella
Dark Phoenix (Phoenix #2)
Book
Black magic. An immoral enemy who will stop at nothing to get what they want. And death—too...
Fantasy Romance
ClareR (6256 KP) rated Black Cake in Books
Jul 12, 2022
I loved the chapters on the Caribbean island - I felt transported there (or at least I wished I was!). The contrast between the island and the UK was radical, and must have been a shock for the Bennett’s - and for anyone else travelling from warmer climes!
The real story is about Benny and Byron having to relearn everything they thought they knew about their mother. Even her husband hadn’t known the whole story.
This is beautifully told, and it’s one of those books where you turn the last page with a tinge of sadness.
Highly recommended.
The Taken (Spirit Walkers #3)
Book
All Jenna Langley wanted was a chance to finally marry the man of her dreams. But when the spirit of...
Paranormal Mystery Romance
Flame Kissed (Phoenix Rising #1)
Book
You can’t outrun fate. As a phoenix on the run from her Legion, I’ve done my best to stay one...
Paranormal Romance Enemies to Lovers Urban Fantasy Forced Proximity Rejected Mates
Mirrorfall (Ash & Blue, #1)
Book
A magical thing happened to Stef Mimosa when she was only two: she died and an angel confronted...
Science Fiction Urban Fantasy
Dead Days of Summer
Book
Annie Darling, owner of the Death on Demand mystery bookstore, is understandably upset. It isn't...
Well, this was a weird one. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but it wasn't this. We are introduced to the sorority girls in the first chapter by a "chorus," who tells us who lives in each room and a small bit about each one. Except for Margot's room, we're told; Margot is dead.
Then the following chapters detail a snippet of time in each girls' life. Some chapters may take place before Margot's death; others take place after. I was really glad I was reading a hardcopy, because at the start of each chapter, I had to flip back to that first chapter about all of the girls and find that girl's little paragraph or so blurb that introduced them. I could never keep any of them straight--perhaps because there was so many or maybe because most them didn't really stand out to me.
Because yes: I didn't really love this one. The short bits of time spent with each character make it hard to get attached to anyone. While we are technically following the thread of Margot's death, there's really no arc to the story. The book probably speaks to some higher meaning that I just didn't get. Instead it's a bit disturbing (some of the chapters are really awful), and no one is happy at all, which was really depressing. Sure, some of these dark glimpses into people's lives can be a little oddly fascinating, but honestly, it was often horrifying too. For me, it felt like the book was trying to be literary and clever and it just didn't work for me (or, more likely, I'm just not a good candidate for literary, smart books, ha).
For instance, was this one praising or mocking sororities? I really don't know. Margot's death seemed so pointless, so it certainly didn't seem to be doing the idea of sororities any favors. A lot of the book didn't seem to show the sisterhood in a good light. Yeah, I just didn't get it. I'm not sure exactly why I slogged through it, except that the full details of Margot's death aren't completely revealed until the end. I actually liked Margot the best, but she was dead, and yes, that probably sums up this book the best for me.
Overall, this one was too weird for me. I can do dark, but dark, strange, no real plot, and few characters with any redeemable value--it just didn't work for me. I'm sure it is enjoyable for others, especially those that don't need a real plot arc. And I do feel the need to point out that there's a trigger for self-harm, suicide, and eating disorders in this novel.

