
Surgeon Doctor Simulator Game (0 KP) created a post
Mar 2, 2023

Ross (3284 KP) rated The Art of Dying in Books
Aug 15, 2019
Ambrose Parry returns with a second book set in Victorian Edinburgh during its medical and scientific revolution. Where the first book centred around Sir James Young Simpson (and others!) search for the perfect anaesthetic, this book focuses more on the man and his reputation. Edinburgh is still a thriving centre of medical science, and reputation is everything. The book starts with Simpson's reputation being besmirched by rivals and former colleagues, looking to suggest negligence. Will Raven and Sarah Fisher team up again to gradually peel away at the facts underlying the case in question and reveal some disturbing trends.
While the plot itself, and its numerous twists and turns, is not exactly ground-breaking, it is excellently told, with clues scattered here, there and everywhere. And to weave this tale around actual historic events and cases really appeals to my mind.
This book, and its predecessor, is one of the most immersive books I have read in a long time. The reader really gets to feel as if they are in Victorian era Edinburgh. Admittedly, I read a fair part of this book while commuting to work in Edinburgh (indeed my children were all born in the Sir James Young Simpson maternity unit of the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary), but I feel the reader with less connection to the city would still get that same feeling.
There is again an underlying message of the treatment of women during those times (and indeed today), both how they are treated in the household and society and also their opportunities for a career and to explore their skills. Sarah Fisher is a strong female character who tolerates her place in society but yearns to break through the glass ceiling, proving her worth to all and sundry as she goes.
In contrast, Will Raven is somewhat spineless in this regard. He sees the issues with society but doesn't do much to act on it. Indeed, he starts the book having run away from Edinburgh and his chances of a relationship with a mere housekeeper, for fear of his heart dooming his medical career. Raven does get some amount of development, both in terms of his medical career, and also in terms of becoming the Victorian equivalent of "woke".
Parry's prose is fantastic and she (they?) truly allow the reader to feel the story unfold around them.
An utterly wonderful book with some interesting history lessons and important messages about the past that should help us build a fairer society today.

Health Tips 1000 FREE! Best Daily Healthy Tip & Diet Advice for a Happy and Fitness Life!
Medical and Health & Fitness
App
1000+ Top Health Tips! This amazing app gives you a rich collection of 1000+ interesting and...

NEJM iPad Edition
Medical and Health & Fitness
App
The NEJM iPad Edition is a rich issue experience that combines all content from the New England...

Anatomy & Function: A 3D Visual Reference of the Human Body
Medical and Education
App
***** Anatomy & Function offers hundreds of interactive presentations that review anatomy and basic...

Pediatric Critical Care Medicine: 2014: Volume 4: Peri-Operative Care of the Critically Ill or Injured Child
Derek S. Wheeler, Hector R. Wong and Thomas P. Shanley
Book
The second edition of Pediatric Critical Care Medicine spans three volumes, with major sections...
Strange Histories: The Trial of the Pig, the Walking Dead, and Other Matters of Fact from the Medieval and Renaissance Worlds
Book
Strange Histories is an exploration of some of the most extraordinary beliefs that existed in the...

The Prose Brut and Other Late Medieval Chronicles: Books Have Their Histories. Essays in Honour of Lister M. Matheson
Jaclyn Rajsic, Erik Kooper and Dominique Hoche
Book
The histories of chronicles composed in England during the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries and...