Sass Perilla (36 KP) rated Frankenstein in Books
Aug 9, 2019
My hatred for and frustration with the self-pitying, feckless behaviour of the (pseudo)
protagonist made this an irritating read for me- and to an extent I think this was Shelley’s intention. Victor isn’t designed to be the likable, affable, morally “good” man fallen from grace he believes himself to be, and the horrific events that befall those around him are of his making.
However, this doesn’t make him any less grating! The "monster" (to me reminiscent of Caliban with his lyrical speech and enforced isolation, being neither man nor not man) is eloquent and persuasive when he asks his creator to account for his misdoings. So, you’ve got to ask yourself, if an infanticidal, demonic, bag of sew together corpses is actually more engaging than the main storyteller, is that storyteller really the
right character to be telling the story?
Now, with all that said, it is an important book. A work by a female author with strong female characters (albeit background characters) who was only nineteen when she wrote the initial draft. Very impressive. But, for me her youth is evident. When we teach secondary school pupils to write creatively, we often give them the ambiguous instruction “show don’t tell”, and for me the book is more of a list of horrible and horrific events told in a Chinese puzzle box style story within a story, rather than an engaging and “complete” narrative. It feels like she chooses to place focus on the wrong “bits”- for example the whole of chapter nineteen where Victor travels the British Isles, comments briefly on the local architecture of each town and city and
then repetitively reminds us that he couldn’t enjoy the surroundings because of his angst.
And I would have at least like to have seen some of the courtroom drama when Victor is tried for the death of Clerval...
So, I hate to be “that” gal, who poo-poos these fantastic works of fiction (we know they’re great because some clever-britches told us they were) but in all honesty, the novel ain’t that good, and I’ll maintain that stance no matter how clever the britches of the opposing schools of thought.
I think the continuing appeal is in it’s universal themes: parenting, nature versus
nurture; morality and scientific advancement- and the whole idea of stitching a creature out of
corpse-parts and electrocuting it to life is pretty darn cool. And there are some really effective
horror scenes, such as the vignette of Victor ripping apart project lady-monster (I kind wish she had a name- a working title- but given he can’t even be bothered to name monster number one I guess this was all too much to hope for).
It’s readable, but it’s value, for me at any rate, lies in the offshoots and creativity it has spawned, rather than the work itself.
Lybrate - Consult a Doctor
Medical, Health & Fitness and Stickers
App
Lybrate – Consult a Doctor is India’s #1 Medical platform connecting over 10 million users to...
Curious George Goes Camping by i Read With
Book and Education
App
**A Children eBook Awards Silver Winner - Best Language Development and Early Childhood App** **A...
Cry Translator
Medical and Lifestyle
App
Now, you can easily figure out what your baby needs with the Cry Translator. This award winning...
Ovia Fertility Period Tracker
Medical and Health & Fitness
App
*** Track your cycle | Get pregnant up to 3x faster! *** Track your period, ovulation, symptoms,...
JKZ Series1
Health & Fitness
App
Dr Jon Kabat-Zinn’s Series 1 – NOW available as an app! The Series 1 mindfulness meditation app...
Period Tracker Deluxe
Health & Fitness and Lifestyle
App
Period Tracker, the easiest way to track your health! *Now supports HealthKit, 3DTouch, TouchID,...
Kurio – App Berita Indonesia
News and Lifestyle
App
Want to read more news that is more accurate and "sane"? Kurio is the place. Enjoy completeness of...
Lingokids - English for Kids
Education and Entertainment
App
Lingokids is the best English learning app for kids aged 2-8. Now featuring content from Oxford...
Bloomz: For Teachers & Schools
Education and Social Networking
App
One app for all your parent communication. Bloomz is the FREE award-winning app that saves teachers...