Heather Cranmer (2721 KP) created a post
Aug 30, 2020
Bunk: The Rise of Hoaxes, Humbug, Plagiarists, Phonies
Book
Kevin Young traces the history of the hoax as a peculiarly American phenomenon—the legacy of P. T....
history politics social issues
That Inevitable Victorian Thing
Book
Speculative fiction from the acclaimed bestselling author of Exit, Pursued by a Bear and Star Wars:...
Science fiction
The Fall of the House of Fifa
Book
Fifa was founded in 1904 to unite the football-playing world, its first congress stating that 'no...
sports
The Sacred Art of Stealing
Book
Let us prey … The press tend to talk about bank robberies as being daring, ingenious and...
Soul of Discretion
Book
CAN YOU KEEP A SECRET Simon Bridgeworth believes in loyalty, and keeping things in-house. When he...
M_M Contemporary Romance Suspense
The Bush Tea Murder (A Caribbean Island Mystery #1)
Book
Culinary journalist Naomi Sinclair is cooking up a maelstrom of trouble upon her return to the blue...
Culinary Cozy Mystery
Best in Murder (A Mac Faraday Mystery # 15)
Book
One Collar. Two Dead. Total Chaos. When a priceless platinum-and-diamond collar vanishes at the...
Mystery Cozy Mystery Police Procedural Dogs Murder
Death in Luxor
Book
SHE FOR WHOM THE SUN SHINES Undercover artifact theft investigator Stefanie Adams and handsome...
Phil Leader (619 KP) rated The Moonstone in Books
Nov 20, 2019
The Moonstone of the title is a rare yellow diamond, stolen from an Indian shrine by colonialists. Thought to be unlucky it is left to the young Rachel Verinder. The night after her 18th birthday party the stone is stolen from her rooms, and the rest of the novel describes how the various players eventually manage to solve the crime.
The plot features twists and turns galore, false trails and red herrings enough for two detective stories. Although the crime involved is 'only' theft rather than the more usual murder it is no less engaging as a story. The characters are well drawn and - social reformer that Collins was - there are strong women and intelligent and interesting servants as well as the landed gentry and philanthropists that inhabit the world of country estates in the mid 19th century that the novel is set in.
One feature of the book is that the story is told from the viewpoint of a number of the players. Firstly (and for nearly half the book) we are introduced to the Verinders and the theft by Gabriel Betteredge, a long serving family retainer who is head of the staff and a sort of de facto butler. Betteredge's narrative is charming and witty, full of dry asides and observations. His habit of picking passages from Robinson Crusoe and applying them to daily life is a quirk that is completely in keeping with his character.
Once the story moves to London, the narrative is taken up by various other characters, sometimes just for a short journal entry, sometimes for extended periods of time. Collins imbues each of these parts with a different voice really skillfully, keeping each character very separate.
The solution to the mystery of who stole the diamond and why is convoluted but also very simple. The whole story is well crafted and fits together really well.
The only negative points really are those imposed on Collins by the time he was writing this. There is an overlong introduction about the diamond in India (it seems that in Victorian novels the long winded introduction is somehow expected by the reader) and the pace slows somewhat in London as there is a lot of description about the character's social standings and financial affairs that just aren't as relevant today.
Nevertheless this really is as good a book as I remember. I certainly rate Collins a lot higher than Charles Dickens as a writer. Definitely recommended for anyone who likes a detective mystery which will keep the reader guessing until the very end.
