Search
David McK (3562 KP) rated No Haven for the Guilty (Hawk & Fisher, #1) in Books
Jan 30, 2019
Set primarily within one location (a house) over the course of one night, this book - for me,at least - is the very definition of a 2-star rating.
Basically a swords and sorcery whodunnit, this is never going to win any awards for either storytelling or originality: I found the denoument to be rather obvious, for instance.
Basically a swords and sorcery whodunnit, this is never going to win any awards for either storytelling or originality: I found the denoument to be rather obvious, for instance.
Merissa (12911 KP) created a post
Mar 23, 2022
David McK (3562 KP) rated Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency in Books
Jun 29, 2025
Well.
This is hard to describe.
Which is probably to be expected from the author of The Hitch-Hikers Guide to the Galaxy.
Slightly dated now (set in the 1980s, we're now in 2025), this is a sort of time travelling whodunnit with a twist of romance thrown in, that probably deserves more to be read than to be described.
Not as famous as THHGTTG series, perhaps, but still worth reading.
This is hard to describe.
Which is probably to be expected from the author of The Hitch-Hikers Guide to the Galaxy.
Slightly dated now (set in the 1980s, we're now in 2025), this is a sort of time travelling whodunnit with a twist of romance thrown in, that probably deserves more to be read than to be described.
Not as famous as THHGTTG series, perhaps, but still worth reading.
The Stricken Land (20 KP) rated Murder on the Orient Express (2017) in Movies
Mar 2, 2018
Ponderous retelling of the Christie novel.
This update of Agatha Christie's famous whodunnit certainly looks the part, and the who's who cast certainly give it their all. But for all its visual splendour, the film fails to really engage and is let down by plodding pace and bloated run time. Akin to watching a beautiful piece of antique furniture for two and a half hours.
Bells On Her Toes
9.0
Rate It
Book
DCI Peter Hatherall is called in to investigate a shooting on the Earl of Ditchburn’s country...
Crime Whodunnit Police Procedural Horse Racing
BobbiesDustyPages (1259 KP) rated One of us is Lying in Books
Feb 5, 2019 (Updated Feb 5, 2019)
A Breakfast Club whodunnit!
Okay I have to say I was completely shocked with just how much I enjoyed this one! I am not really a fan of mysteries in general because I always guess the ending no matter how cleaved the book/show thinks they're being. But when it came to One Of Us Is Lying is just couldn't put it down. I guessed the ending a little before the halfway point but it didn't bother me at all since McManus kept throwing more curve balls that had me second guessing myself.
Dork_knight74 (881 KP) rated Knives Out (2019) in Movies
Jun 27, 2020
Great!
This "whodunnit" was a surprisingly spirited and fun watch. I thought it would be a spoof of old school mystery movies but it wasn't. The acting was phenomenal and the cinematography spot on. Everyone played their characters wonderfully and the story unfolded beautifully. Some of it was predictable but it had plenty of twists and turns throughout the entire film and kept you guessing until the end.I highly recommend watching it. While younger kids may not understand all of it, it's a movie the whole family can enjoy. REALLY worth a watch!
Knives Out (2019)
8.3
Rate It
Movie Watch
Pastiche whodunnit from writer-director Rian Johnson. When a successful mystery writer is found...
Suswatibasu (1703 KP) rated Blood Ties in Books
Oct 10, 2017 (Updated Oct 10, 2017)
Thanks to NetGalley for my copy of this book. A great combination of intrigue, mystery and even a touch of the supernatural, this whodunnit is filled with a fair few climactic twists. DI Charlie Moon returns having to work against the grain after his suspension from duty, even hiring the help of a local journalist to solve this gruesome murder. While the conclusion may have ended abruptly, it culminates in the ultimate karmic retribution. Jenny Francis manages to capture both the idyllic countryside and the brutality of injustice in one swoop of her pen. An enjoyable read.
Suswatibasu (1703 KP) rated The Girl Before in Books
Jul 27, 2017
A little bit formulaic and unoriginal
As much as this has been dubbed the next Girl on a Train, that was part of the problem - it was too much the same. A slightly neurotic protagonist, and a typical tyrannical male character with a dash of Christian Grey involved.
The structure was well done, going back and forth the different narratives, so it was totally reminiscent of the different stories in Girl on a Train. Because of the formulaic story, the whodunnit ends up becoming predictable. You just need to choose which tyrannical male character it could be. Slightly disappointed but still readable.
The structure was well done, going back and forth the different narratives, so it was totally reminiscent of the different stories in Girl on a Train. Because of the formulaic story, the whodunnit ends up becoming predictable. You just need to choose which tyrannical male character it could be. Slightly disappointed but still readable.