Gareth von Kallenbach (980 KP) rated Water for Elephants (2011) in Movies
Aug 7, 2019
Jacob appeals to the vanity of the heartless circus owner and ringmaster, August, convincing him to keep him on as the circus veterinary doctor. One of his first patients is the horse of the circus’ star attraction, Marlena, who also happens to be August’s wife. When Marlena’s horse is replaced by an elephant, Jacob is made responsible for the elephant’s care and training. This gives Marlena and Jacob a common ally in Rosie, the elephant, and a common enemy in an increasingly violent August. Cue the furtive glances, the stilted conversations and awkward moments that signal the start of the mutual attraction between Marlena and Jacob.
While Jacob, Marlena and August form the romantic triangle that drives the story, it’s Rosie and the circus backdrop that provide the more entertaining aspects of the movie. Director Francis Lawrence (Constantine and I Am Legend) pays decent attention to period detail, highlighting the desperation and brutality of The Great Depression while romanticizing the ephemeral circus life and the subversive lifestyles enjoyed in defiance of The Prohibition. Sadly they were just quick peeks into a curious world.
Based on a best-selling novel of the same name by Sara Gruen, Water for Elephants is a sweet tale told in retrospect by a 90-something-year old Jacob, played by a wistful Hal Holbrook. Robert Pattinson plays young Jacob capably, and I have no doubt his fans will swoon at the many close ups of his brooding stare, pained grimaces and the occasional delighted smile. While this character gives him a few more lines than his more well-known role as Edward, the tortured vampire of the Twilight saga, it was difficult to watch him and not see the similarities in how he portrays Jacob and Edward. Reese Witherspoon’s Marlena was in turns adequately fragile and sufficiently steely. With negligible chemistry, Pattinson and Witherspoon’s performances paled in comparison to that of Christoph Waltz whose sadistic August was played with cunning zeal.
A carefully told story, Water for Elephants is however too carefully told, in a predictable, pedantic pace. However, fans of Pattinson will not be disappointed.
Full Circle: The Rise, Fall and Rise of Horse Racing in Chelmsford
Book
In the 18th and 19th centuries Chelmsford Races at Galleywood were the most eagerly anticipated...
Bad Magic and the Big Top (Blackwood Bay Witches Paranormal Cozy Mystery)
8.0
Rate It
Book
Welcome to Blackwood Bay, where magic and murder have come out to play...Life for fledgling new...
Mark @ Carstairs Considers (2579 KP) rated Lost and Clowned in Books
Jun 17, 2026 (Updated Jun 17, 2026)
The characters are grounded for a circus setting; in fact, the book is a bit more serious in tone than I was expecting. It took me a bit to get all the characters straight, but I was soon able to. Pi felt a bit immature to me a time or two, but it was minor. Likewise, the pacing stalled a couple of times, but nothing that lasted long. There were some good surprises and twists along the way to the logical climax. I enjoyed the Northern California setting. This appears to be a rare cozy standalone, but if we get a sequel, I will gladly revisit these characters. Those looking for an unusual cozy will be glad they picked this one up.
Kelsey (4 KP) rated The Night Circus in Books
Jan 4, 2019
Who's Gonna Pay For That
Podcast
Co-Hosts David Rohde & Maxx Eckert run into the circus fire that is American, Texas, and Denton...
Aokana: Four Rhythms Across the Blue
Video Game
In a world where flying through the sky is as simple as riding a bicycle, the sport "Flying Circus"...
Torture Garden (1967)
7.0
Rate It
Movie
Amicus horror anthology. A group of visitors to a circus sideshow get the chance to take the...
anthology
A Coney Island of the Mind
Book
The title of this book is taken from Henry Miller's "Into the Night Life" and expresses the way...