David McK (3219 KP) rated Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011) in Movies
Aug 11, 2019
With no Orlando Bloom or Kiera Knightley in sight, the focus on this one is firmly on Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow (a character who initially, remember, way back in the first film, was not the main focus), although it has to be said that his Keith Richards schtick is perhaps getting old by this point in the franchise.
Standout sequence of the film? That would be the Whit Cap bay mermaid bit.
Thenford: The Creation of an English Garden
Anne Heseltine and Michael Heseltine
Book
This book is the story of one garden and one family, over a 40-year time period. In their own words,...
The Alpha Beta Book: An Introduction to Ancient Greek
Book
Can learning Ancient Greek ever be fun? Keith McCrary sets out to show: of course it can! The book...
Popular Culture and Political Agency in Early Modern England and Ireland: Essays in Honour of John Walter
Michael J. Braddick and Phil Withington
Book
One of the most notable currents in social, cultural and political historiography is the...
Richard III: From Contemporary Chronicles, Letters and Records
Keith Dockray and P.W. Hammond
Book
No English king has suffered wider fluctuations of reputation than Richard III, perhaps the most...
Ingmar Bergman
Robin Wood and Barry Keith Grant
Book
At a time when few reviewers and critics were taking the study of film seriously, Robin Wood...
Flight of the Amazon Queen: 20th Anniversary Edition
Games
App
"A great game, that'll give you hours of fun and leave you feeling good. We love it!" -Mr. Bill's...
The Boy Who Drew Monsters
Book
From the New York Times bestselling author of The Stolen Child comes a hypnotic literary horror...
Acanthea Grimscythe (300 KP) rated The Motion of Puppets in Books
May 16, 2018
Theo and Kay Harper are newlyweds with a ten year age difference between them. A teacher at a local college, Theo takes an summer vacation away from New York with his wife, Kay, as she performs with a cirque in Quebec City. While she works, he translates a book from French to English, and everything appears to be fine. That is, until Kay suddenly disappears one night after going out with her fellow actors for dinner and drinks. Woven with necromancy, animated puppets, and many references to the madness of Alice in Wonderland, Donohue's story could be considered riveting, and perhaps I would gladly label it so if I had not been so profoundly bored while reading it.
The book's plot is, in and of itself, highly intriguing. As a fan of horror and having proclaimed a love for anything necromantic in nature, the idea of people becoming puppets, or even dying and being reanimated in any fashion really, is something apt to catch my attention, and for that reason and my love of ancient mythology, I requested an advanced reader's copy of The Motion of Puppets. My frustration with it came mostly in the fact that I felt like the book progressed too slowly and there seemed to be a lot of extra "fluff" added in. For instance, the snippets regarding Theo's translation of Eadweard Muybridge's biography really felt a bit unnecessary. There was no real correlation between Muybridge and the book itself, save to provide Theo with something on which to focus. That, also, didn't feel necessary, as Theo seems to be a rather detached character, despite his very clear obsession with his wife. Even Kay's point of view seems to be a bit overly deluded, considering her time as a puppet is significantly shorter than that of the other puppets around her and yet she seems almost as aloof as they are by the conclusion of the book.
In addition to moving at a bit of a slow pace, The Motion of Puppets also seems to rely a bit more on Alice in Wonderland-like elements than it does mythos or current happenings. Everything seems weird and ridiculous, and little, if anything, makes any sense. If you try to make sense of it, chances are you'll find yourself lost, which I found myself giving up on halfway through the book. Magic is clearly alluded to as being the cause for the current state of the majority of the cast's existence; however, it is hardly mentioned and never really explained. Clearly there's enough oddness going on that the nearly-faceless bad guys worry about being found out, but even that isn't enough of a reason to delve into the why or how: it simply is.
There is no doubt in my mind that Keith Donohue is an excellent writer; he has a beautiful command of language that quite literally takes my breath away. Though The Motion of Puppets failed to satisfy me as a reader, I will likely read more of his work when I have the time. As for the genre of this book, horror probably isn't the right one. It'd be better suited in fantasy. There's nothing scary here.
Thank you to Macmillan-Picador, NetGalley, and the author for providing me with an advanced reader's copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Big Carp Magazine
Sports and Magazines & Newspapers
App
For over 20 years Big Carp has been the serious carp anglers favourite read. Written and read by the...