Chris Hooker (419 KP) rated Shots on the Bridge: Police Violence and Cover-Up in the Wake of Katrina in Books
Jan 12, 2018
[Shots On The Bridge] by [Ronnie Greene] is a good piece of investigative journalism about one of the most notorious events in post-Katrina New Orleans.
As most people I was glued to my TV all throughout Katrina and I remember the news reports of a shoot out on a bridge involving police. As I recall the news reported that it was gangsters and looter shooting at the police. There were many reports of this nature in the confusion following one of the worst disasters in U.S. history. We now know that most of these reports were embellished at best or just down right lies.
[Ronnie Greene] did an excellent job relating the events as they occurred and giving a voice to the victims. The fact that these families were just trying to cross a bridge and came under fire by an overly armed unit of police is disconcerting enough but the fact that the police conspired to cover it up makes it even worse. Although it was wrong I could understand the officers reaction to the call of shots fired given the trauma that they had also been through. It is the cover up and lies that compound the wrongfulness of their actions.
I though [Greene] did a good job but he seems to jump around a bit too much. There is a lack of fluid transitions. Also, I feel his view was very one sided. I know that the police did something horrible but they were victims of Katrina as well and probably should not have been on duty at that point. If the correct relief and support had been provided this whole situation may have been avoided.
Whilst I understand that America’s post counter-culture, folksy racism/ misogyny/ homophobia [insert prejudice here] is subject to criticism by the author, there was more than one occasion where I found the discriminatory language jarringly unnecessary. It really dates the piece.
That said, on the whole, this is a really excellent read, and I was in equal parts disgusted and amused by the antics, and found myself (to some degree of shame) identifying with some of the scrapes and situations the Doctor of Journalism and his legal crony got themselves into- I mean who hasn’t found a casualty or two in their bathrooms following an impromptu house party? (Although I do wonder how events might read to those who avoided misspending their youth...)
It’s a short, pithy searing indictment of American culture, society and the tacit implication (or actually come to think of it- pretty explicit statement) that substance abuse is the only way to deal with and make sense of the chaos. So, one could argue, still pretty relevant.
Violence is frequently a first recourse, the idealisation of capitalism is metaphorically “burned to the ground” (yet antithetically also a cause for admiration) and towards the end a primate bites into an old man’s skull. What’s not to like?
The Age for iPad
News and Magazines & Newspapers
App
Experience trusted and independent news on the go with The Age app. The app brings together...
The SMH for iPad
News and Magazines & Newspapers
App
Experience trusted and independent news on the go with The Sydney Morning Herald app. The app...
Vladimir Jabotinsky's Story of My Life
Brian J. Horowitz and Leonid Katsis
Book
Vladimir Jabotinsky is well remembered as a militant leader and father of the right-wing Revisionist...
Poetic & Real Worlds of Cesar Vallejo (18921938): A Struggle Between Art & Politics
Book
The world-renowned Peruvian poet Cesar Vallejo (18921938) was also a journalist, essayist, novelist...
Life Itself: A Memoir
6.0
Rate It
Book
Roger Ebert is the best-known film critic of our time. He has been reviewing films for the Chicago...
On Company Time: American Modernism in the Big Magazines
Book
American novelists and poets who came of age in the early twentieth century were taught to avoid...
Domesticating Drones: The Technology, Law and Economics of Unmanned Aircraft
Henry H. Perritt and Eliot O. Sprague
Book
The public debate over civilian use of drones is intensifying. Variously called "unmanned aircraft...
The Lost Boys: Inside Football's Slave Trade
Book
From South America and Africa, kids as young as 13 are leaving poverty-stricken families for a new...