Robert Eggers
20 favorites
Movies & TV Writing
Robert Neil Eggers is an American film director, screenwriter and production designer. He is best...
Roberta Eggers Studer
(1 KP)
Last Active: Jan 15, 2018 
The Lighthouse (2019)
7.2
Rate It
Movie Watch
Two lighthouse keepers try to maintain their sanity during a violent storm, whilst living on a...
The Witch (2015)
6.3
Rate It
Movie
A devout Puritan family in 17th century New England is slowly torn apart by evil supernatural...
The VVitch A New-England Folktale
The Northman (2022)
7.9
Rate It
Movie
The Northman is an upcoming epic revenge thriller, that explores how far a Viking prince will go to...
KarynKusama recommended The Lighthouse (2019) in Movies (curated)
Best Music Writing 2007
Daphne Carr and Robert Christgau
Book
Rappers, rockers, emo-boys, jazz snobs, and poptimists alike eagerly anticipate each edition of Best...
BankofMarquis (1832 KP) rated The Lighthouse (2019) in Movies
Jan 25, 2021
Add Robert Eggers’ THE LIGHTHOUSE to this list.
Based on a real life tragedy from 1801, THE LIGHTHOUSE follows 2 isolated Lighthouse keepers as they interact with each other, slowly going mad in the process…or did they? Is one of them mad and the other sane? Are they both mad? Or…is it the viewer who is going mad? Eggers let’s you, the viewer, decide.
And…good for him. I have now encountered 2 films directed by former Production Designer Eggers - THE WITCH and now this film. In both cases, the movies are interestingly shot and intriguing to view but almost incomprehensible. The more so with THE LIGHTHOUSE, it is almost as if Eggers heard the criticism of THE WITCH of being incomprehensible and said “hold my beer”.
Besides the production values - which really are quite good (especially Eggers use of Black and White) - what holds this movie in high regards is the acting of the 2 people in film. These 2 characters are the only speaking parts in this movie.
Willem Dafoe portrays the older, veteran Lighthouseman who tells the tales of Mermaids and Curses and has a generally air of foreboding from the start. It is a masterwork by Dafoe - his best work of his career (and that’s saying something). He is unnerving to view from the start. The only thing the viewer needs to figure out is whether he is insane or very, very, very sane.
The surprise for me in this movie is the work of Robert Pattinson, the younger Lighthouseman who is in his first assignment. He is the audience’s eyes into this weird world and he is very much sane at the beginning. At the end…well…you decide. He was able to go toe-to-toe with DaFoe and held his own very well. This young actor has made a conscious choice following the Twilight films and with this movie and with Christopher Nolan's TENANT he is establishing himself as a darn good performer.
As for the film itself, my one recommendation for you is to not be too concerned of making sense of what is going on in the scene you are watching…you’ll drive yourself mad doing this (at least it was driving me mad). After awhile I just sat back and drank in the weirdness - and the quality acting and production values - that was enfolding in front of me and the ending was satisfying (enough).
All in all one of the stranger times I’ve had at the movies.
Letter Grade: B
7 stars (out of 10) and you can take that to the Bank (ofMarquis)